Source: sjvwater.org
Kern River trial date moved back eight months
Fetched 2026-08-04 08:00 from sjvwater.org
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: Kern River Trial Date Moved Back Eight Months
Key Facts
- Trial to determine whether the City of Bakersfield must re-evaluate Kern River operations has been pushed to October 4, 2027 (from February 2026), an eight-month delay.
- The California Supreme Court agreed in July 2025 to review a 5th District Court of Appeal ruling from April 2025 that overturned a 2023 injunction by Kern County Superior Court Judge Gregory Pulskamp requiring water flow for fish.
- Oral arguments at the Supreme Court could begin as early as September 2025; one scheduling conflict (attorney Colin Pearce, Sept. 8–11) has already been flagged.
- The underlying 2022 lawsuit centers on whether Bakersfield must study its river operations under the Public Trust Doctrine.
- The Kern River ran dry again after July 30, 2025, when the city’s Kern River rights used to sustain spring/summer flows ran out.
Who Is Affected
- City of Bakersfield (primary defendant)
- Plaintiff advocacy groups: Bring Back the Kern, Water Audit California
- Water rights holders: Kern County Water Agency, Kern Delta Water District, North Kern, Buena Vista, and Rosedale-Rio Bravo Water Storage Districts
- Kern River ecosystem and fish populations dependent on in-stream flows
- Bakersfield residents relying on river access and urban river corridor
Policy/Legal Angle
- California Fish and Game Code Section 5937: Requires dam owners to release enough water to keep fish in good condition — the basis for Pulskamp’s overturned injunction.
- Public Trust Doctrine: Requires California waters be put to the highest beneficial use, including environmental and public access values — the core issue in the underlying trial.
- 5th District Court of Appeal ruling (April 2025): Held that a court must first quantify fish water needs and balance them against existing uses before issuing an injunction — a significant procedural hurdle for fish flow advocates.
- The Supreme Court’s pending ruling on Section 5937 scope could reshape how fish flow obligations apply statewide, not just on the Kern.
Blog Angles
- What’s actually at stake at the Supreme Court? The 5th District’s “quantify first, balance second” standard could make it dramatically harder to enforce Section 5937 anywhere in California — worth unpacking how a Kern River case could set precedent for every dammed river in the state.
- 150 years of water rights vs. modern public trust obligations: The defendant water agencies argue river operations are locked in by agreements dating back over a century. How much legal insulation do historical water rights actually provide against evolving public trust standards?
- The dry river problem in real time: The river flowed April–July 30, then went dry again. Is the city’s use of its own rights to maintain flows a sign of good faith, or an inadequate half-measure — and what would a genuine public trust analysis actually require?
Full Text
Kern River trial date moved back eight months
The trial to determine whether the City of Bakersfield must re-evaluate how it operates the Kern River was bumped another eight months to October 4, 2027, at a court hearing on Monday.
The case was set to be heard in February next year, but the parties agreed to move it back as the state Supreme Court gears up to hear arguments on a crucial piece of the case possibly as early as next month.
Though the issues are different in the underlying lawsuit and the portion of the suit being heard by the state Supreme Court, a ruling from the justices could influence the rest of the case.
Justices agreed to review a ruling by the 5th District Court of Appeal that overturned a temporary injunction that was issued by Kern County Superior Court Judge Gregory Pulskamp in 2023 to keep some water in the river.
Pulskamp had required water be allowed to flow in the river based on California Fish and Game Code Section 5937, which requires dam owners to let enough water run downstream to keep fish in good condition.
River rights owners appealed Pulskamp’s order stating he first needed to determine how much water was needed and then balance that need against existing uses for the water. The 5th District Court of Appeal agreed and overturned the ruling in April 2025.
River advocates Bring Back the Kern and Water Audit California then appealed to the Supreme Court, which agreed to review the issue in July 2025. That triggered a blizzard of briefs from all sides until June when the high court announced it was ready to hear oral arguments as early as September. So far, only one attorney, Colin Pearce who represents Bakersfield, has notified the court that he has a conflict Sept. 8-11, and the court agreed to black out those dates.
There are a multitude of other attorneys involved who could similarly request the court not schedule arguments for certain dates, so it’s still unclear when exactly arguments will be held.
Meanwhile, the underlying case against Bakersfield brought by Bring Back the Kern and Water Audit California in 2022 has continued. The main issue in that case is a quest to have Bakersfield study how it operates the Kern River under the Public Trust Doctrine. That doctrine requires all waters in the state be put to the highest beneficial use, which can include public access and the environment.
Given that agricultural diversions leave the river through town dry most of the time, the plaintiffs have argued that the city has been derelict in its public trust requirements.
The city and other Kern River rights holders, including the Kern County Water Agency, Kern Delta Water District and the North Kern, Buena Vista and Rosedale-Rio Bravo water storage districts, have argued river operations are dictated by layers of rights, contracts and agreements going back more than 150 years.
The city used some of its Kern River rights to keep water flowing through town from April through July 30 this year. But those rights petered out and the river ran dry again .