Source: mavensnotebook.com
HEALTHY RIVERS AND LANDSCAPES: Westlands Water District to end participation in Bay-Delta Program absent reversal by the State
Fetched 2026-09-05 08:00 from mavensnotebook.com
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: Westlands Water District Threatens HRL Program Exit
Key Facts
- Westlands Water District announced it will exit the Healthy Rivers and Landscapes (HRL) Program unless the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) reverses course on its final draft Bay-Delta Plan (released August 19).
- The HRL Program originated from a March 2022 MOU among state, local, and federal agencies and public water agencies, formerly known as the Voluntary Agreements.
- The 2022 MOU was designed as a science-based, basin-wide alternative to traditional flow regulation, pairing new flows with habitat restoration, dedicated funding, and adaptive governance.
- Westlands argues the SWRCB’s final draft retains the HRL name but abandons the negotiated substance, effectively reverting to the regulatory approach the program was meant to replace.
- General Manager Allison Febbo stated Westlands will “pursue other viable pathways” if the State does not honor the 2022 commitments in full.
Who Is Affected
- Westlands Water District – serves farmers and rural communities on the west side of Fresno and Kings counties
- State Water Resources Control Board – the regulatory body whose final draft triggered the dispute
- Other public water agencies that co-signed the 2022 MOU and have participated alongside Westlands
- Central Valley agricultural communities dependent on water-supply reliability
- Bay-Delta ecosystems and fish species whose conservation outcomes were central to the program’s environmental goals
Policy/Legal Angle
- No specific statutes or court decisions are cited, but the core dispute is a contract/MOU integrity question: whether the SWRCB is legally or politically obligated to honor commitments made in the March 2022 MOU
- The HRL Program was explicitly framed as an alternative to traditional regulatory action under the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan — Westlands argues the final draft collapses that distinction
- Westlands’ threat to exit raises questions about whether the SWRCB can proceed with an HRL framework if major water contractors withdraw, and what fallback regulatory mechanisms apply
Blog Angles
- What specifically changed between the 2022 MOU and the August 19 final draft? The article is heavy on grievance but light on specifics — a blogger could dig into the SWRCB’s released plan to identify which flow requirements, habitat commitments, or governance structures were altered, and whether the Board’s own record justifies the changes.
- Is Westlands’ exit a negotiating tactic or a genuine off-ramp? The conditional framing (“absent reversal”) suggests leverage. A blog post could examine whether other water agencies are making similar threats and assess how much political pressure this puts on the SWRCB before the plan is finalized.
- What are the “other viable pathways” Febbo referenced? This phrase is unexplained — it could mean litigation, federal coordination, or a separate state legislative strategy. Tracing those options would make for a strong forward-looking policy piece.
Full Text
HEALTHY RIVERS AND LANDSCAPES: Westlands Water District to end participation in Bay-Delta Program absent reversal by the State
From the Westlands Water District:
Westlands Water District will not continue in the Healthy Rivers and Landscapes (HRL) Program under the terms set out in the State Water Resources Control Board’s final draft Bay-Delta plan. The final draft retains the HRL name while abandoning the commitments the parties negotiated in 2022.
Formerly known as the Voluntary Agreements, the HRL Program grew out of a March 2022 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) among state, local, and federal agencies and public water agencies after multiple years of analysis and collaboration. This innovative agreement envisioned the development of a comprehensive, basin-wide, science-based alternative to traditional regulation: one intended to improve environmental health and species conservation while providing water reliability for California communities and farms.
Westlands committed to that approach because it paired new flows with habitat restoration at scale, provided dedicated funding, and established a rigorous science program, all under a governance structure built to adjust management actions as the science developed. Those elements remain the right foundation for the Bay-Delta. The final draft released on August 19 keeps the HRL name but changes the terms of the agreement, departing from what the parties negotiated to the point that the Program’s purpose is no longer achievable.
Since 2022, water agencies including Westlands have participated in good faith, devoted significant time and resources to negotiations, and submitted detailed comments as the draft water quality control plan evolved, ensuring it remained consistent with the agreement memorialized in the 2022 MOU. Throughout this process, the State Water Resources Control Board has included elements in successive drafts that undercut the comprehensive, science-based approach embodied in the 2022 MOU. Despite repeatedly raising detailed concerns, the issues remain unresolved, and the agencies’ comments have been rejected rather than meaningfully addressed. The final draft moves the HRL Program back toward the regulatory approach it was created to replace.
Reversing that outcome requires the State to honor its agreement. Absent a final plan that honors the 2022 commitments in full, Westlands’ participation in the HRL Program will end.
Statement of Allison Febbo, General Manager, Westlands Water District:
“The Healthy Rivers and Landscapes Program was built on sound science and a shared commitment to improve environmental outcomes while strengthening water-supply reliability for California’s farms and communities. That was the promise of the 2022 agreement Westlands supported. Unfortunately, the final draft has moved significantly away from both the substance and collaborative spirit of that agreement, abandoning the balance the parties spent years working to achieve. Westlands cannot support a program that has departed so significantly from its original purpose. Westlands remains committed to comprehensive, science-based solutions and will pursue other viable pathways that prioritize water security, reliable supplies, and a sustainable future for our growers and Central Valley communities.”
About Westlands Water District: Westlands Water District is recognized as a world leader in agricultural water conservation and has served the farmers and rural communities on the west side of Fresno and Kings counties for more than seven decades. As stewards of one of California’s most precious natural resources, Westlands continually invests in conservation and champions farmers deploying innovative irrigation methods based on the best available technology.
BAY-DELTA PLAN: State Water Board releases final draft plan to protect California’s Bay-Delta, water and wildlife
BAY-DELTA PLAN: State Water Board releases final draft plan to protect California’s Bay-Delta, water and wildlife