Source: mavensnotebook.com
SJV WATER: Groundwater agencies seeking relief from state sanctions will have to pay $50k-$250k just to apply
Fetched 2026-09-23 08:02 from mavensnotebook.com
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: SGMA “Good Guy” Exemption Application Fees
Key Facts
- The California Water Resources Control Board approved fees of $50,000–$250,000 (tiered by pumping percentage) just to apply for a “good guy” exemption from SGMA probationary sanctions.
- The Board spent $1.3 million reviewing all Tule subbasin exemption requests; without application fees, those costs were spread across all SGMA fee payers.
- Only two agencies — Kern-Tulare Water District GSA and Delano-Earlimart Irrigation District GSA — were granted exemptions; both will pay $12,500 annually to maintain them.
- Of $7 million billed in Tule subbasin probation fees, only $2.16 million has been paid; 85 farmers are protesting $3.27 million in invoices.
- Fewer than 35% of Tulare Lake subbasin farmers reported their pumping to the state, versus ~65% in the Tule subbasin.
Who Is Affected
- Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in the Tule and Tulare Lake subbasins, covering the southern San Joaquin Valley flatlands and most of Kings County
- Tule subbasin farmers (Tulare County) currently under probation and receiving state invoices
- Tulare Lake subbasin farmers (Kings County) — invoices on hold pending an October 6 court hearing
- Eight denied GSAs in the Tule subbasin that sought but failed to obtain exemptions
- All SGMA fee payers statewide, who were previously absorbing exemption-review costs
Policy/Legal Angle
- Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA) — specifically its “good guy” exemption clause allowing individual agencies to avoid probationary fees
- Probationary fee structure: $300/well annually for metering and registration + $20/acre-foot pumping fee to the state
- A court hearing on October 6 will determine whether Tulare Lake subbasin farmers must begin paying probation invoices
- The newly approved application fee structure was set by Water Board staff to balance cost recovery without “discouraging legitimate exclusion requests”
Blog Angles
- Access vs. accountability: At $50K–$250K just to apply, are exemption fees effectively pricing out smaller or less-resourced GSAs from even attempting to avoid probation — and does that undermine the “good guy” clause’s intent?
- Compliance gap in Tulare Lake: With fewer than 35% of farmers reporting pumping data, how can the state accurately bill or enforce fees — and what enforcement tools does the Water Board actually have?
- The $3.27 million protest pile: Who are the 85 farmers contesting invoices, on what grounds, and what does the protest rate signal about SGMA’s political durability in Tulare County?
Full Text
SJV WATER: Groundwater agencies seeking relief from state sanctions will have to pay $50k-$250k just to apply
By Lisa McEwen, SJV Water
Any groundwater agency hoping to independently avoid state sanctions under the so-called “good guy” clause of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA) will have to pay between $50,000 and $250,000 just to be considered.
That’s how much the state Water Resources Control Board staff says it costs to review the technical and often voluminous exemption requests.
The $50,000 to $250,000 tiers are based on the percentage the requesting groundwater agency pumps from the subbasin and are intended to “…cover appropriate staff expenditures with the need to avoid discouraging legitimate exclusion requests,” according to David Ceccarelli, branch chief with the Division of Water Quality.
The Water Board approved the good guy application fees at its Sept. 15 meeting and got an update about how well – or not – Tulare County farmers have been paying other fees.
The good guy exemption application fee will cover what had become an unanticipated cost, Ceccarelli said at the meeting.
Without it, “…those costs are effectively borne by all SGMA fee payers,” he said.
Exemptions are the only way individual agencies can avoid fees when a subbasin is placed on probation by the Water Board for lacking an adequate groundwater plan. Under probation, farmers must meter and register wells annually at $300 each, and pay a $20-per-acre-foot fee to the state – on top of existing fees paid to groundwater agencies.
So far, the state has placed two San Joaquin Valley subbasins on probation, including the Tule, which covers the southern half of Tulare County’s flatlands, and the Tulare Lake subbasin, which covers most of Kings County.
Only two agencies within those subbasins were granted exemptions, the Kern-Tulare Water District and Delano-Earlimart Irrigation District groundwater sustainability agencies.
They did not have to pay the just-approved application fees but will have to pay 25% of their pumped groundwater total to maintain their exemptions.
Essentially, those GSAs will pay a fee to avoid probationary fees.
Delano-Earlimart Irrigation District GSA general manager Eric R. Quinley said it is his understanding that the GSA will pay $12,5000 for an annual review to maintain its exclusion .
“DEID is not opposed to paying a fee for the state board’s legitimate work of implementing SGMA in Tule subbasin,” Quinley said. “Reviews are part of that larger effort.”
Delano-Earlimart is considered a “net-postive” district because it imports more surface water than its growers extract.
Kern-Tulare will pay the same, $12,500, to maintain its exemption, according to board member Andrew Hart. Farmers there extracted just 437 acre feet from 37 wells in 2025.
Eight other groundwater agencies in the Tule subbasin sought exemptions earlier this year but were denied .
Ceccarelli said it cost the Water Board $1.3 million to evaluate all the Tule subbasin exemption requests, including Delano-Earlimart and Kern-Tulare.
Probation fees rolling in
The board also heard a report about how much Tulare County farmers have paid toward well registration and pumping fees required under probation.
State invoices went out in August and, so far, a little more than $2 million has been paid of $7 million billed, according to Water Board staff.
Staff reported that 114 Tule subbasin farmers have paid $2,161,000. Another 85 farmers are protesting their invoices, which total $3,265,000. Another $1.9 million owed by 107 landowners is outstanding.
Pumping fees are based on how much was reported by farmers. Staff estimated that about 65% of Tule subbasin’s farmers reported their groundwater use.
Farmers in the neighboring Tulare Lake subbasin are not paying invoices yet pending the outcome of a court hearing on Oct. 6. Fewer than 35 % of Tulare Lake farmers reported their pumping to the state, according to state data.