Source: www.circleofblue.org
Who Will Pay for Climate Reporting?
Fetched 2026-10-18 08:00 from www.circleofblue.org
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: “Who Will Pay for Climate Reporting?”
Circle of Blue, 2026
Key Facts
- U.S. newspaper reporter and editor jobs dropped by 1,300 in 2025, and roughly 60% of print newsroom jobs have vanished since 2005 (Medill Local News Initiative/BLS data)
- Digital newsrooms also cut 1,300+ jobs in 2025, meaning no sector of journalism is absorbing the losses
- 194 TV segments on summer heat waves aired across ABC, NBC, and CBS — not one connected the events to climate change (Media Matters analysis)
- Nearly 8% of U.S. counties have no locally based news source (Medill)
- The New York Times earned $2.8 billion in revenue in 2025 but is increasingly driven by games/recipes subscriptions rather than hard news
Who Is Affected
- Rural and local communities — most vulnerable to news deserts, least likely to receive locally translated climate/water coverage
- Nonprofit newsrooms — Inside Climate News, Grist, Investigate Midwest, Baltimore Banner, Texas Tribune, ProPublica — absorbing displaced environmental reporters but at reduced scale
- Defunct outlets — Hakai Magazine and California Sunday Magazine cited as cautionary casualties of funder withdrawal
- Iowa communities — used as a case study: farm chemical/water pollution/cancer reporting by Circle of Blue (begun 2022) has now become a governor’s race issue by 2026
- Flint, Michigan residents — referenced for how lead pipe removal only became national policy after racial inequity and local crisis converged
Policy/Legal Angle
- No specific laws or court decisions cited, but key policy-adjacent themes include:
- The role of journalism in government oversight and democratic accountability
- Lead drinking water pipe removal as a delayed policy outcome (D.C. early 2000s → Flint catalyst → national action)
- Iowa governor’s race framing of agricultural water pollution as a live political/regulatory issue
- Implicit tension around public funding for journalism as an emerging revenue experiment
Blog Angles
-
The Iowa Water Pollution Story as a Template: Circle of Blue’s four-year reporting arc linking farm chemicals, water pollution, and cancer rates to a governor’s race offers a direct model — what would it take for California’s ag water contamination issues (nitrates in the Central Valley, etc.) to reach similar political salience, and who is doing that sustained reporting here?
-
California’s Local Water News Deserts: With 8% of counties nationally having no local news source, which California counties — particularly rural, agricultural, or tribal — lack local outlets covering water quality and drought decisions that directly affect them? Who fills that gap?
-
Funder Dependency Risk for Water Journalism: The article flags that one major foundation pulling out can collapse a nonprofit outlet (Hakai Magazine being a pointed example for West Coast environmental coverage). Which foundations are currently funding California water journalism, and how concentrated — and therefore fragile — is that funding ecosystem?
Full Text
The news business, if you haven’t heard, is a mess.
Against the worrisome backdrop of a steep drop in newsroom jobs, 38 climate and environment reporters gathered at Flathead Lake Biological Station, in Montana, in early October for two days of in-depth talks. Representing big metro dailies, national print and radio outlets, and nonprofit pioneers, we had an impossibly large task: discuss the future of climate journalism.
Though reporters are busy telling the stories of our rapidly changing world, the news business is in a two-decade decline. U.S. newspaper reporter and editor jobs dropped by 1,300 in 2025, according to the Medill Local News Initiative using data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Since 2005, about 60 percent of newsroom jobs at the country’s print publications have vanished. Add to that, digital newsrooms, the disruptive newcomers, witnessed a net cut of more than 1,300 journalism jobs last year.
Along with the journalism jobs market, trust in institutions is plunging nationwide. Gallup polling indicates that only Congress ranks lower in Americans’ esteem than newspapers or TV news. A presidential administration openly hostile to the press only sows more doubt about the bona fides of the Fourth Estate. Talk about unsettling findings for an industry that is critical to the functioning of a democratic society.
How about climate reporting? Network news, for one, is strangely silent on the topic of climate change. Media Matters, an industry watchdog, analyzed coverage of U.S. heat waves in June and July at ABC, NBC, and CBS and found that the climate context was…well, absent.
“Not one segment connected the nearly back-to-back extreme heat events to climate change, including segments that described the conditions as historic, exceptional, or record-breaking,” Evlondo Cooper of Media Matters wrote. The three networks aired 194 segments about the heat waves over a four-week period.
This was the context for climate and environment reporters gathered in Montana. Organized by the Institute for Journalism and Natural Resources, the convening was part graduate seminar, part brainstorming session, part group therapy. It was an opportunity for frank conversations about the impediments to covering a gargantuan story that touches everything.
Above all, what business models will sustain it?
The advertising-driven model failed a generation ago with the advent of the public internet. Hedge fund and corporate owners have bled city papers dry. Some of the survivors – the Salt Lake Tribune, for one – have transitioned to a nonprofit structure. The New York Times, a legacy behemoth with more than $2.8 billion in revenue in 2025, is an outlier and nearly as much a games and recipes business as a hard news organization, at least in terms of subscribers. Revenue experiments pop up everywhere – events, public funding, sponsored content – but it’s safe to say an industry-wide solution has been elusive.
Nonprofit outlets, large and small, have taken up some of the slack and performed admirably. ProPublica, now cultivating local news talent, is the gold standard and a perennial winner of national reporting prizes for uncovering misdeeds and corruption. Smaller newsrooms at Investigate Midwest, Inside Climate News, and Grist have absorbed talented environmental reporters let go elsewhere. Local and state nonprofits like the Baltimore Banner and Texas Tribune are an invigorating presence. Still, staff numbers are a fraction of those during the news-gathering heyday, and national-scale nonprofits, despite the quality of their work, have different audiences than those reached by local newspapers, which can translate climate change, and provide relevant details, for the people directly affected.
Reader support is essential for community connection and can be a vital source of funding. But that’s often not enough to keep small and rural news outlets afloat. Nearly 8 percent of counties have no locally based news source, Medill found . Many nonprofits rely on the same pool of large foundations, which can be fickle in their interests. One major funder pulls out and the whole enterprise is at risk of toppling. RIP Hakai Magazine and California Sunday Magazine.
In Montana, I moderated a panel on measuring the impact of reporting. I posed two questions to frame the discussion: Impact for whom? And impact to what end?
Those questions led to a series of corollaries. Is an informed citizenry not enough? In a quantified era of metrics and KPIs, do journalists need to prove their worth to funders by documenting whether their stories remake society? Is that an unfair standard? Policy change is often a hallmark of accountability reporting, but change can take years to ferment.
In that vein, do funder goals and timelines align with the goals of journalism? Circle of Blue started reporting on the links between farm chemicals, water pollution, and rising cancer rates in the Midwest in 2022. Four years later, after public agitation that was facilitated by scientific assessment and a continuous stream of reporting from local and national outlets, those issues are now leading concerns in the Iowa governor’s race. Political prominence for Iowa’s polluted waterways was not an overnight phenomenon.
Often large-scale change requires the right mix of timing and luck. Lead in drinking water spiked in Washington, D.C., in the early 2000s. But removing lead drinking water pipes did not become a national imperative until outrageous circumstances of racial inequity and penny-pinching aligned in Flint a decade later.
News outlets are the lungs of the body politic, circulating information to the citizenry in the same manner as oxygen. In this instant-gratification, short-attention span age, is an informed public enough justification for readers and foundations to invest in the hard work of news gathering and government oversight? Or does the enterprise require more voice, more style, fewer words, more video, more something else?
We did not cure journalism’s woes in two days at picturesque Flathead Lake. But I think we posed the right questions as industry pressures – and the temperature – continue to rise.
Lead image: Wildfire smoke clouds the sun in northern Michigan in July 2026. Photo © J. Carl Ganter/Circle of Blue
Brett writes about agriculture, energy, infrastructure, and the politics and economics of water in the United States. He also writes the Federal Water Tap , Circle of Blue’s weekly digest of U.S. government water news. He is the winner of two Society of Environmental Journalists reporting awards, one of the top honors in American environmental journalism: first place for explanatory reporting for a series on septic system pollution in the United States (2016) and third place for beat reporting in a small market (2014). He received the Sierra Club’s Distinguished Service Award in 2018. Brett lives in Seattle, where he hikes the mountains and bakes pies. Contact Brett Walton
Circle of Blue WaterNews
Your support helps inform the world’s most important decisions about water and all that it touches.
We’ll send a verification code to %EMAIL% .
Sign up for newsletters
Get the best of Circle of Blue directly in your email inbox.