Source: sjvwater.org
MEETING NOTES: Public demands greater transparency, desert groundwater board approves budget
Fetched 2026-10-21 08:00 from sjvwater.org
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: Indian Wells Valley Groundwater Authority Meeting (Oct. 14, 2026)
Key Facts
- Inyokern Community Services District settled a legal dispute with the Indian Wells Valley Groundwater Authority (IWVGA), agreeing to pay $62,968 and comply with authority requirements going forward.
- The authority’s approved budget includes $125,000 for communications plus an additional $25,000 for hearings and forums; the board agreed to shift lobbying/PR firm Westbound Communications (Orange County) to an as-needed basis rather than full contract.
- The Kern County District Attorney issued a report alleging that AB 1413 and AB 1466 were supported by Ridgecrest City Council members without an open-session vote, potentially violating the Brown Act.
- AB 1466 (Gregg Hart, D-Santa Barbara) passed; AB 1413 (Diane Papan, D-San Mateo) failed.
- The board approved the budget with Board Member Saint-Amand voting no.
Who Is Affected
- Inyokern Community Services District — party to the now-settled legal dispute
- Indian Wells Valley Water District — initiated basin adjudication; its board representative (Saint-Amand) was excluded from closed-session litigation discussions
- Ridgecrest City Council — named in DA report regarding potential Brown Act violations
- Small groundwater pumpers in the Indian Wells Valley basin — directly affected by AB 1466’s court treatment provisions
- Residents of the Indian Wells Valley — concerned about water supply sustainability and authority transparency
Policy/Legal Angle
- Ralph M. Brown Act (California open meetings law) — central to allegations that lobbying efforts through Capital Core (lobbyist Michael McKinney) and council support for AB 1413/1466 occurred without proper public notice or open-session votes
- AB 1466 — now law; requires courts to treat small pumpers separately in adjudication actions and accept groundwater agency reports on those pumpers
- AB 1413 — failed; would have required judges to use groundwater agencies’ “sustainable yield” figures in adjudications
- SGMA/Groundwater Sustainability Plan — budget line retained to preserve capacity to respond to Department of Water Resources requirements, even as adjudication proceeds in parallel
Blog Angles
- Brown Act Enforcement Gap: The DA report names Ridgecrest City Council members but the IWVGA’s own lobbying role through Capital Core remains murky — did the authority itself circumvent public input requirements when directing legislative advocacy? What did the DA’s report actually conclude, and will there be consequences?
- Dueling Strategies — GSP vs. Water Rights Acquisition: Multiple board members and public commenters pushed to deprioritize groundwater sustainability plan administration and redirect resources toward buying water rights. This raises the question: is SGMA compliance becoming a procedural shell while the real water future of the valley gets decided in court?
- $125K Communications Budget in a Hostile Community: The Westbound Communications situation — a firm hired to improve the authority’s image that instead “aggravated the community” — is a concrete case study in how groundwater agencies struggle with public trust. What does effective (and cost-justified) public outreach actually look like for a contested desert basin agency?
Full Text
MEETING NOTES: Public demands greater transparency, desert groundwater board approves budget
Meeting: Indian Wells Valley Groundwater Authority Date: October 14, 2026 Agenda and Packet: CLICK HERE
Settlement announced
The Inyokern Community Services District agreed to settle a legal dispute with the Indian Wells Valley Groundwater Authority, Authority Legal Counsel Keith Lemieux announced following closed session.
Inyokern CSD agreed to pay the authority $62,968 and follow the authority’s requirements going forward.
Transparency questions
During public comment Jennifer Slayton questioned the authority board in regards to its lobbying group, Capital Core, asking if the group had pursued legislation without proper board action.
“Are we sure that all of the things that we have asked Capital Core to pursue have been done lawfully with an opportunity for the public to have input in open session or reported out of closed session, so that we can have a voice as we have a right to do?”
Slayton’s comments come after a report from the Kern County District Attorney that alleges Assembly Bills 1413 and 1466 were supported by members of Ridgecrest City Council without a vote being taken in open session, which could be a violation of California’s Ralph M. Brown Act governing open meetings.
AB 1466, authored by Gregg Hart (D-Santa Barbara), which passed, requires courts to treat small pumpers separately in larger adjudication actions and accept groundwater agency reports about those small pumpers.
AB 1413, authored by Diane Papan (D-San Mateo), which failed, would have required judges to use the “sustainable yield” figure produced by groundwater agencies.
Mike Sinnott questioned if Michael McKinney of Capital Core had helped write the bills, which he said could be in violation of the Brown Act.
In response, Authority Board Member David Saint-Amand, who is also a board member of the Indian Wells Valley Water District, said that the water district representative on the authority has been excluded from closed session matters on litigation, including the assembly bills in question. The Water District initiated the adjudication in the basin.
Saint-Amand stated that if the authority board violated the Brown Act the water district representative was not a part of it.
Judy Decker expressed disappointment that the authority had not prioritized buying water rights for the Indian Wells Valley.
April Keigwin, general manager for the authority, presented the authority’s annual budget in which the amount set for communications was $125,000 and an extra $25,000 for hearings and forums.
Many audience members, including Slayton, said that was too high.
She said friends with communications businesses were shocked at that amount. She also noted that Westbound Communications, of Orange County, was supposed to help improve the authority’s image. Instead, she said, most of the social media posts the company put out only served to aggravate the community.
Saint-Amand made a motion to cut all funding for Westbound.
However, Keigwin said, that would leave her to work on the new website alone.
Board members John Vallejo and Phillip Peters were also not content with the high Westbound budget but noted that they did not want to completely strike communications from the budget.
Keigwin suggested hiring Westbound on an as-needed basis and that when Westbound’s contract ends in December the authority could look for another agency. The board agreed.
Director Phillips asked if the authority needed a separate amount budget for administration of the groundwater sustainability plan considering many of the issues contained in the plan are being hashed out through a legal adjudication process.
He, instead, felt the authority should focus on buying water rights to supplement finite native sources.
”At some point we have to quit these duplicative efforts and focus on what the result is and that is getting water and getting it here, so I would like to see that prioritized,” said Peters.
Keigwin said the budget item doesn’t reflect any new work on the groundwater plan. It is in place in case the Department of Water Resources has further requirements and the authority needs to respond.
The board approved the budget with Saint-Amand voting “no.”