Source: sjvwater.org
Valley flood protection still a hodgepodge, leaving bald spots and confusion
Fetched 2026-11-06 08:01 from sjvwater.org
Reading Summary (AI-generated)
Reading Summary: Valley Flood Protection Still a Hodgepodge
Key Facts
- The Fresno Metropolitan Flood Control District has a coordinated system with ~75 staff, storm drains, sumps, FID canal integration, and up to 30,000 acre-feet of storage at Big Dry Creek Reservoir — but covers only a fraction of Fresno County.
- There is no overarching flood control agency for the southern San Joaquin Valley, leaving most areas without coordinated protection.
- Mill Creek (eastern Fresno County) flooded Wonder Valley in 2023 with no governing agency; Wonder Valley Ranch Resort suffered “hundreds of thousands of dollars” in damage, including a complete loss of its archery range.
- In Madera County, a checkerboard of federal and non-federal levees has left landowners confused about maintenance responsibilities, and the county lacks legal authority to work on non-federal land.
- Most ephemeral streams — those only active in major water years — have no governance at all.
Who Is Affected
- Fresno Metropolitan Flood Control District and Fresno Irrigation District (FID) — functioning but limited in jurisdiction
- Wonder Valley Ranch Resort (Kalene Ramirez, CEO) — private business left to self-protect along ungoverned Mill Creek
- Madera County Flood Control Agency (Kevin Sischo) and Madera County Water and Natural Resources (Stephanie Anagnoson) — operating with jurisdictional and legal constraints
- Private landowners and farmers throughout Madera and Fresno counties — unclear on responsibilities and regulatory risk
- Rural communities and agricultural lands along ephemeral streams across the southern San Joaquin Valley
Policy/Legal Angle
- California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) permits are normally required for clearing streambed overgrowth and debris — a regulatory barrier to pre-flood preparation.
- Governor Gavin Newsom’s emergency order explicitly grants landowners authority to clear overgrown creek beds without a permit — but landowners remain skeptical and distrustful of that protection.
- Madera County has no legal right to perform work on non-federal levee land, creating a hard jurisdictional boundary that leaves maintenance gaps.
- The absence of a regional flood control authority for the southern San Joaquin Valley is a structural governance gap, not just a resource gap.
Blog Angles
- The governance vacuum question: Who should have authority over ungoverned ephemeral streams like Mill Creek — and what would it take legislatively or administratively to create a regional flood control framework for the southern San Joaquin Valley? The 2023 floods exposed this gap; has Sacramento responded?
- Emergency orders vs. on-the-ground reality: Newsom issued an emergency order allowing streambed clearing, yet farmers still don’t believe they’re legally protected. What does this trust gap reveal about how California communicates emergency regulatory changes to rural landowners — and does the order have teeth?
- The Fresno model as a template: The Fresno Metropolitan Flood Control District appears to work well through multi-agency coordination (FMFCD + FID). Why hasn’t this model been replicated or expanded to cover the rest of Fresno County or neighboring counties, and what are the financial and political barriers?
Full Text
Valley flood protection still a hodgepodge, leaving bald spots and confusion
- Editor’s note: Allison Hunter covers Fresno County water issues for SJV Water through the California Local News Fellowship initiative.
When it comes to how prepared San Joaquin Valley communities are for potential El Niño-fueled flooding, it’s down to three things: location, location and location.
In the Fresno area, for instance, the Fresno Metropolitan Flood Control District has a robust system that’s “ready to go,” according to Assistant General Manager Brent Sunamoto.
The district funnels excess water through a series of storm drains and into sumps. As those systems fill, it can also move water through Fresno Irrigation District (FID) canals into FID recharge facilities. “When the basins fill up too high, we could go and flip a switch and turn a pump on and basins will pump that water into the FID canal,” Sunamoto said.
His team of about 75 clears channels, does preventative pump maintenance and other work year round. The district can also store up to 30,000 acre feet in the Big Dry Creek Reservoir from some foothill streams.
That coordination works well for the fraction of Fresno County under the flood agency’s jurisdiction.
But most of Fresno County doesn’t have that kind of well-resourced, coordinated flood response. In fact, there is no overarching flood control agency that covers the southern San Joaquin Valley.
In 2023 there was significant confusion over who had authority and responsibility to protect communities in the path of floodwater.
Some water districts and municipalities have authority over some sections of rivers, and some agencies have control of some levees. But there is limited coordination between those entities.
And most ephemeral streams, those that only come to life in huge water years, typically have no governance at all.
That’s the case with Mill Creek in the low foothills of eastern Fresno County. Mill Creek flooded out Wonder Valley in 2023 and businesses along its banks are pretty much still on their own.
Kalene Ramirez, CEO and president of Wonder Valley Ranch Resort, said the 2023 storms cost the company “hundreds of thousands of dollars” in damage. Two buildings flooded and several trees had to be cut down, Ramirez said. The archery range, which backed up to the property’s fence line and the creek, suffered the most.
“This entire thing just floated away,” Ramirez said, referring to the archery range. The resort has since added a second range, repaired its fence and removed several trees. It also added more soil to cover the washed-out path where Mill Creek overflowed, creating a second channel.
Ramirez said they’ve done all they can to ensure the property is prepared for the potential big water year.
“You know, you want to think you’re covered,” she said. “But we know we don’t really know for sure.”
Similarly, in Madera County, a checkerboard of federal and non-federal levees has left landowners confused about which ones they’re responsible to maintain – if at all.
Kevin Sischo, water resources specialist for the Madera County Flood Control Agency, said “people don’t have a distinction” of which levees are their responsibility.
He added that the county doesn’t “have the legal right” to work on non-federal land. It’s up to the landowners.
When it comes to streambeds, California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) permits are typically required to clear overgrowth and trash, except if it’s deemed “ emergency work ,” according to the CDFW website .
This year, an emergency order issued by Governor Gavin Newsom expressly gives landowners authority to clear overgrown creek beds, which caused major problems in 2023.
But landowners don’t know – or trust – that they won’t get in trouble without a permit, said Stephanie Anagnoson, Madera County’s Director of Water and Natural Resources. “When I was talking to a farmer earlier today, he didn’t believe me,” Anagnoson said.